The Ethics of Porters

02/10/10  Print This Post Print This Post    4 Comments      Written by Catherine Thompson
    Share
Feature photo: Ai@ce/Above Photo: Licht3
Catherine Thompson questions the ethical treatment of porters while hiking Kilimanjaro.

One more deep breath and another step. I can see my goal.

I’m so close and then I’m there: the first person of the morning to reach the summit of Kilimanjaro. The sun breaks through the clouds and lights up the glaciers. I’m lucky enough to have arrived before the hoards of other climbers.

The five days of walking, two blisters and 5, 895 meters were completely worth it.

However, the thrill of my success was tempered by concern. During the climb, I grew wary of how the porters accompanying us were treated.

We had two guides and many porters with us; they carried our tents, our food, and equipment. They taught me some Swahili. Our head guide even pulled an extra sweater from his pack when I was freezing.

Without these men, I would not have accomplished my goal.

Porters in Kenya-Ai@ce

As I got to know the porters who walked with us everyday, I learned about the conditions they worked under. I found out that they crowded into the kitchen tent to sleep after we ate and subsisted on the group’s leftovers for food. Many of the porters had no warm clothes, only t-shirts and open-toed sandals.

I saw men tossing supplies over bushes at a checkpoint to pass weight inspection before picking up the items on the other side.

According to the Kilimanjaro Porters Assistance Project,

“The Kilimanjaro National Park recommends that a porter carry 20 kg for the company, but the average reported weight is 23 kg and can be as high as 30 kg.”

The Kilimanjaro Porters Assistance Project

I explored the streets of Moshi on the day after our climb and came across the Kilimanjaro Porters Assistance Project. All my suspicions were confirmed. They told me that porters are often underpaid, underfed and not properly equipped for the conditions on the mountain.

We found out that most of the porters never receive the portion of the tip meant for them. (We made the mistake of giving our tip to the head guide and expecting he would divide it among the men.)

The Kilimanjaro Porters Assistance Project is dedicated to improving the conditions of the porters who climb Kilimanjaro. They teach classes, provide first aid certification and lend warm clothing to porters for their climb. The organization also educates the public about the porters’ working conditions and gathers information to help monitor travel companies’ treatment of porters.

Even though climbing Mt. Kilimanjaro was an amazing experience, I now know that it is ethically important for travelers to be aware of the working conditions of porters before using their services.

After learning more about the porters during our five days on the Rongai Route, we donated two sleeping bags and our coats to the porters.

What you can do

Consult a list of companies that treat their porters with respect.
Visit the Kilimanjaro Porters Assistance Project.

COMMUNITY CONNECTION:

Our own Matador associate editor, JoAnna Haugen, co-founded a fund for Machu Picchu Porters.


    Share

About the Author

Matador ID: Catherine Thompson

Catherine Thompson has spent the last few years traveling the world and has set foot on every continent. This is her first article but she is hoping to write many more.

4 Comments... join the discussion!

  • Ross replied on February 10, 2010

    Great piece! I’ve climbed lots of mountains and used porters more than a couple times on the bigger mountains like Kili and getting into base camp on Aconcagua.

    I’ve seen them mistreated by the “guides” and by other climbers. It sucks. I think the best thing you can do on the mountain is treat them with respect and tip well. I’m also very vocal when I see someone mistreated on the mountain. Whether it’s another climber or their boss, getting called out on it will make an impression on the person and the porter will appreciate you standing up for him.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • Alyssa replied on February 10, 2010

    awesome article. so glad you brought this to attention of Matador community…

    I hope to read more from you!

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • Cathey replied on February 10, 2010

    So much of this breaks my heart. No personal experience of my own, but I agree with Ross. Speaking up when someone is out of line would be an absolute must for me. Thanks for sharing this and getting coverage on it.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • Nancy replied on February 11, 2010

    Thanks for sharing your experience and writing about this issue, Catherine. Before reading your and JoAnna’s experience with porters, I never even realized this was going on.

    One day I hope to do a big hike like Kilimanjaro or Machu Picchu and now I will definitely make sure it’s with a responsible company that treats its porters with respect.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply

Leave a Comment

Get Matador in your inbox and around the web.

Sign up for our FREE weekly newsletter.


View full list of RSS feeds

Jump To Category:



Explore the Community



Popular Stories on Matador

Meet an Expert: Egypt

Meet Nick Rowlands. He's our man with the master plan i... 

How To Reconnect With Your Friends After The Journey

Life isn't on pause when you leave town. ... 

Friday Fun: The One Hit Wonder Down Under

The snow’s long gone in the northern hemisphere, but ... 

3 Exercises for Free Divers

Expert free diving is almost Zen-like, a union between ... 

Gracefully Becoming A Golden Oldie

The advantage of youth is obvious. Rosie Horne shows us... 

The Hazards of Coming Home: Moving Back In With Mom & Dad

Anne Merritt ponders the comforts and contradictions of... 

Logging Off: How to Deal With Internet Addiction

Think you're addicted to the internet? Admitting it is ... 

John Lennon: The Lost 1969 Interview On Peace

38 years after it was recorded, an impromptu interview ... 

Dive the Great Lakes, Save a Shipwreck

The Great Lakes contain some of the best-preserved ship... 

Ultimate Burning Man Packing List: 50+ Items To Bring To BRC

The first step to a successful trip to



Focus


Blogroll




Editor Blogs