Higher Taxes For Country Living: A British Proposal

12/1/09  Print This Post Print This Post    4 Comments      Written by Juliane Huang
  • Stumble It

Ah, life’s simple pleasures. Photo: Kecko

Country living: urban dream and environmental nightmare?

While the rest of the world’s populations are flocking toward their nation’s metropolitan hotspots, a 2001 British census shows that Brits have been forgoing the fast-pace of the city for slower country living, a trend that has only gotten worse in recent years.

Not okay, says University College London research associate and author P.D. Smith in an article published in Wired UK magazine’s January issue.

Smith cites data revealing rural households emitting higher carbon dioxide than their urban counterparts due to larger residences, longer commutes, and multiple cars. Turns out, the regions with the largest carbon footprints in the UK are in the rural northeast, not the famed cities of London or Glasgow. London, interestingly enough, has the lowest per capita emissions. Who would have thought?

Smith argues that city living creates a low carbon economy and those who opt for country living should be taxed for the luxury.

“British people need to be cured of the insidious fantasy of leaving the city and owning a house in the country…. We tax cigarettes to reflect the harm they do to our health: we need to tax lifestyles that are damaging the health of the planet – and that means targeting people who choose to live in the countryside.”

Making exceptions for agricultural workers and those who are employed in rural areas, Smith wants to institute a “Rural Living Tax” for all other country residents, such as rich people with two houses.

But other than tax the pants off country dwellers, isn’t a better solution to aggressively promote greener living for all citizens?

Rather than punish people for choosing to live with cows and chickens, we should be encouraging the habitual acts that contribute to sustainability. The Earth is everyone’s responsibility and finding more reasons to tax certain demographics doesn’t exactly carry that message across.

Sound reasonable enough? Let those opinions fly free in the comments below.


  • Stumble It

About the Author

Matador ID: juliane

Juliane Huang currently writes for Matador from the beautiful city of San Francisco. With a laptop in one arm and a travel bag in the other, Juliane is rarely at home, though always online. Catch up with her on her blog.

4 Comments... join the discussion!

  • Keith replied on December 2, 2009

    I’m British.

    I have only one word to say. You probably wouldn’t print it, but it rhymes with ‘frolics’

    Are there any plans to tax Mr, Smith for all the hot air he’s putting out, which must contain a large amount of CO2?

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
    • Juliane Huang replied to Keith on December 2, 2009

      HAHA he certainly is emitting something…

      (Report comment)

      ↵ Reply
  • XtremXpert replied on December 2, 2009

    I live in a rural area, we have 2 big houses, a carpenter workshop, 2 stables a small hydroelectric dam and an old car. Yes, maybe for 6 people we produce higher carbon dioxide than 6 city residents, but we live on 4 hectares. How much carbon dioxide is produced on 4ha on the city? Anyway, good for my parents there isn’t a tax like that in Romania too.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
    • Juliane Huang replied to XtremXpert on December 2, 2009

      I doubt Smith’s proposed tax will actually become reality; it just seems so absurd.

      (Report comment)

      ↵ Reply

Leave a Comment

Get Matador in your inbox and around the web.

Sign up for our FREE weekly newsletter.


View full list of RSS feeds

Jump To Category:





Popular Stories on Matador

Gringos In Mexico And That Elusive Quest for Authenticity

We got out of the bus in Mitla, blinking, stumbling, li... 

Review: TELL ME MORE® French

Candice Walsh reviews some innovative

How To Respectfully Visit Holy Places Around The World

... 

Gracefully Becoming A Golden Oldie

The advantage of youth is obvious. Rosie Horne shows us... 

Notes from a Cargo Ship Deckhand [PHOTOS]

Marty Machado logs the last leg of a 6-month tour as a ... 

How to be More Comfortable on Camera

Are you camera shy? Try some of these techniques to fee... 

The World's Most Spectacular Skylines

Here are staggeringly beautiful images where city meets... 

Top 10 International Ski Mountains to Hit in 2010

There's a lot of snow, and a lot of snow sports, in the... 

5 Indoor Spots for All-Weather Adventure

Five of best places in the world to practice adventure ... 

VOTE: What Are Your Favorite Things at Home?

Some things at home just can't be replaced. What comfor... 



Focus


Blogroll


Editor Blogs