From the Editor: How Twitter helped me care about the Burj

01/6/10  Print This Post Print This Post    10 Comments      Written by Julie Schwietert
    Share

Daily life in Dubai*. Photo: Lara Dunston

How two 140 character messages changed my mind about the Burj.

By the time the evening news broadcast on Monday, I was already over the Burj.

I’d seen no fewer than four TV spots with snazzy graphics comparing the height of the Burj to the heights of the Empire State Building, the Willis Tower, the Eiffel Tower.

I’d heard too many redundant comments about Dubai’s wealth (former) and debt (current), too many “analyses” about the “seeming paradox” of a strictly religious people surrounded by such opulent, ostentatious gluttony.

The news cycle may only be 24 hours these days, but sometimes those 24 hours can really seem to drag along.

And so it was that Monday night, right before I signed off the computer for the evening, I banged out an exasperated tweet:

“You know what I don’t care about? The Burj, that’s what.”

Lots of stuff we throw out on Twitter’s blank wall doesn’t stick, but this tweet did.

Matador member Eloren agreed with me, tweeting:

“@collazoprojects Agree.. So fed up of hearing about it. I don’t see what’s to be so proud of? Tsss.”

And Aussie expat journalist Caitlin Fitzsimmons agreed, too:

“@collazoprojects I know! My husband was trying to tell me about it tonight.”

One person didn’t agree, however, and that was travel writer Lara Dunston, who I respect for her professionalism and her genuine and generous support of colleagues, including myself. An expat who has called Dubai home for more than 10 years, Lara tweeted back politely, but firmly:

“@collazoprojects The people who care about the Burj are the people who live there & love the place, and for whom it’s symbolic of so much…”

“@collazoprojects …which is why I care about it; I think we must feel the way Aussies felt when the Opera House or Harbour Bridge opened”

And just like that, with two tweets, I realized that maybe I *did* care about the Burj.

The problem was that mainstream media had totally overlooked the story that Lara was alluding to in two simple tweets.

She elaborates in her description of the photo that appears at the top of this article:

The pic is of Dubai Creek, the historical centre of the city and lifeblood of Dubai, taken from the wharf at Bur Dubai Souq. There’s something happening down here 24 hours a day, but I love it most in the evening when, with the fairy lights are on the dhows (wooden boats in the background)…. This is the first part of Dubai I ever visited when we moved to the UAE in 1998 and it’s still my favorite part….

There were only a handful of shopping malls in the city then, Burj Al Arab had not yet opened and there were no crazy manmade island developments. It cost less than 20 cents to cross the Creek on an abra (the main boat in the pic) then and now it costs around 30 cents. For many people who live in this area, this is the real Dubai.

When Terry and I lived in the city full-time (ie. before we put our things in storage and decided to live out of our suitcases four years ago), we would walk down here to the Creek several evenings a week…. Friday (like Sunday in the Western world) is liveliest when everyone seems to be down there shopping in the souqs. We saw this side of Dubai far more often than we ever saw the sumptuous shopping malls or extravagant five star hotels, which would only be when we’d go shopping and go out on weekends.

For most people in the city, as in any city, the luxe side represented by the media isn’t the side the locals experience every day. The difference is that with New York, Paris or Sydney, the media also makes an effort to discover and report on the everyday life of the city too – in Dubai they’re not interested. And I could write a novel about why that’s so.

The Burj is more than snazzy graphics and a gasp-inducing fireworks show.

And that’s precisely why I was “over” the Burj before I really knew anything about it.

All the coverage was from the outside looking in: “Look how Dubai bested us!”

Nobody but Lara, it seemed, was inside looking out. It took a travel writer’s two tweets to make me aware why I found mainstream media coverage of the Burj so tiresome:

It lacked the human element.

Thanks to Lara for restoring it.

Community Connection:

Read other Matador editors’ takes on the Burj. Hal Amen’s Dubai, the UAE, and the World’s Tallest Building can be found on MatadorTrips, and Tim Patterson’s Could the Burj Kahlifah Collapse? is on MatadorAbroad.

Learn more about Lara in this article from our archives: What’s In Your Backpack, Lara Dunston, Travel Writer?


    Share

About the Author

Matador ID: collazo

Julie Schwietert is the managing editor of Matador Network. She contributed a chapter to the recently published book, The Voluntary Traveler, and is currently working on five features for Fodor's Puerto Rico, 6th Edition.

10 Comments... join the discussion!

  • Tim Patterson replied on January 6, 2010

    Word. Perspective makes all the difference.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • lara dunston replied on January 7, 2010

    Thanks, Julie. I’m really touched that my little tweeps motivated your post. (Although wish I had better-crafted my rambling description of the pic for you!) The fact that the everyday stories, the human element, and, as Tim points out, the many different perspectives, after repeatedly overlooked in most journalist’s desire to either a) gush about the glitz and glam, b) focus on the city-emirate’s faults, and c) boast about its current economic woes, is incredibly frustrating for a writer who has lived in the city since 1998. Fortunately, as a writer/blogger, I have lots of opportunities to present other points of view.

    You may be interested in my latest blog post elaborating on what I was also alluding to, i.e. the parallels with the Sydney Harbour Bridge and other iconic buildings, and why Burj Khalifa is a source of such national pride.

    Thanks again for the kind words! :)

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
    • Julie Schwietert replied to lara dunston on January 7, 2010

      Lara-

      Thanks for your comment, and for the blog post on Cool Travel Guide, which definitely did interest me.
      Why do you think it is that journalists and other writers tend to overlook all these other stories about Dubai?

      (Report comment)

      ↵ Reply
  • Angela replied on January 7, 2010

    Agree, sometimes I tend to read/listen to news or events “from outside”, but it’s the human element that helps us connect with locals, of any country!

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • Eva replied on January 7, 2010

    Great post, Julie.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • Sarah replied on January 7, 2010

    Loved this, Julie. Information goes flying by so quickly on the web that it’s really easy to just glimpse it.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • AdventureRob replied on January 9, 2010

    Great post Julie, media often lacks the personal touch, I think it’s one element why people are migrating to blogs to get it back rather then a national newspaper with a agenda.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • Caitlin @ Roaming Tales replied on January 10, 2010

    That’s a lovely post, Julie.

    I also enjoyed Lara’s post, likening it to the Sydney Harbour Bridge as that’s something that I can really relate to. Not all monumental structures stand the test of time though – that’s something that remains to be seen.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply

Leave a Comment

Get Matador in your inbox and around the web.

Sign up for our FREE weekly newsletter.


View full list of RSS feeds

Jump To Category:



Explore the Community



Popular Stories on Matador

The Importance of 'Quiet Time' During Travel

Experiencing the bustle of a new place is one of the bi... 

How To Reconnect With Your Friends After The Journey

Life isn't on pause when you leave town. ... 

Photo Essay: People Watching in Verdi Square, New York City

The comings and goings of people at Verdi Square, in th... 

Culture Hopping: Life Is The Essential Ingredient

... 

Why Travelers Should Spend Time Instead Of Money

Forget dropping wads of cash. Make sure you stay longer... 

Back to Sender

Lola Akinmade is confronted with the energetic survival... 

Photo Essay: Daily Life Around Monasteries in Burma

What do monks and nuns do when they aren't meditating? ... 

The Cenotes of Riviera Maya, Mexico

Contributing editor Juliane Huang discovers why she nev... 

Climbing the Brooklyn Bridge (Sort Of)

A climbing gym with good hours, its own line of skatebo... 

Bariloche Juxtaposition

"I think about how Nazis³ used to live here and probab... 



Focus


Blogroll




Editor Blogs