America’s homeless population: Protected or punished?

07/8/10  Print This Post Print This Post    7 Comments      Written by Alyssa Martino
    Share

Photo: Michael Hite

Imagine it’s 9 PM on a winter night, and you don’t have a place to stay.

Cold? Think twice before bundling up in a blanket or sleeping bag, as doing so just may result in a warrant for your arrest.

At least it could in Boulder, Colorado.

How and why does the city of Boulder–especially known for its laid back vibe–appear to be criminalizing its homeless population?

The answer–though somewhat baffling–has to do with an anti-camping ordinance, which outlaws sleeping outside with any sort of shelter besides clothing. The law has resulted in Boulder police issuing over 1,600 tickets in the past year, reported The Boulder Weekly reported recently.

Sticking Up for Shelter

Boulder’s only homeless shelter shuts down during summer months, and can only accommodate 160 individuals in the winter–less than 25% of the city’s individuals living on the streets.

Last November, it was this lack of space that led David Madison to be turned away from the Boulder County Shelter. That night, Madison returned to the streets with a sleeping bag to shield himself from the bite of the 11 degree Colorado air.

When the police found Madison, they deemed him guilty of camping. The only reason? His frost-covered sleeping bag.

Should America’s homeless population be left to choose between hypothermia and jail?

The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) doesn’t think so. On June 28th, the ACLU filed a suit in Boulder, calling the anti-camping ordinance unfair and unconstitutional. In a letter sent to the Boulder City Council, the ACLU wrote:

“The City of Boulder has no legitimate interest in criminalizing its residents who are without a home, forced to sleep outdoors in the cold, and merely want to cover themselves in order to survive.”

The ACLU has suggested that the city amend the ordinance to clarify that using a blanket or sleeping bag “by itself” is not shelter. Furthermore, it explained:

“While we continue to believe that the arrest and prosecution of Boulder’s homeless residents under these circumstances violates the Eighth Amendment’s prohibition on cruel and unusual punishment, it is not necessary to wait for a court ruling in order to conclude that these arrests and prosecutions are senseless, and bad public policy.”

Amen to that.

Homelessness by the Numbers

The National Law Center on Homelessness and Poverty estimates that approximately 3.5 million people, 1.35 million of them children, are likely to experience homelessness in any given year. The number of families in homeless shelters even jumped 7% from 2008-2009.

With those statistics, the Obama administration–along with the support of volunteers throughout local communities–has taken on several initiatives to help to those without shelter.

On June 22nd, Obama issued a statement vowing to end homelessness within 10 years. The plan, called “Opening Doors,” grew out of a federal law signed in 2009, requiring the U.S. Interagency Council on Homelessness to develop a plan of action. Though their ideas have only recently been defined on paper, many remain optimistic about the administration’s commitment to this cause.

How Can I Help?

The National Coalition on Homelessness outlines four ways you can help America’s homeless: Contribute, Advocate, Reach out, and Educate, or “CARE.” For more information on each of these activities, visit the organization’s website.

If you’d like to support the ACLU’s efforts to decriminalize homelessness in Boulder, please sign this petition put together by Change.org.

Community Connection:

Want to work hands-on with people affected by homelessness? Check out our Urban Volunteering series, a guide to volunteer opportunities in cities around the world.


    Share

About the Author

Alyssa Martino

Alyssa C. Martino is a copywriter/editor outside Washington, D.C., and has freelanced for several publications and blogs. She is interested in travel, human rights, culture, and change, and is hard-pressed to remember a time when she didn't see writing in her future. Her creative nonfiction is here.

7 Comments... join the discussion!

  • Nancy Harder replied on July 8, 2010

    Thanks so much for this article, Alyssa. I’m often saddened by how America treats their homeless population both in legislation and prejudice. Thanks for the info on how to help.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
    • Alyssa replied to Nancy Harder on July 8, 2010

      Me too, Nancy! I’m glad you found this useful though.

      Thanks for reading :)

      (Report comment)

      ↵ Reply
  • somchai replied on July 8, 2010

    When I was young America had almost no homeless. Then Reagan emptied the mental hospitals.

    You can’t drink in the shelters in Boulder, so many stay out so they can drink. Of course getting plastered and sleeping out can kill you when it’s cold. Boulder is a great town for panhandling, all those guilt ridden rich folk. You can pan handle for a couple hours and make $20, and Liquor Mart on Canyon has great deals on booze.

    The links are great, but even more importanty we need to recognise mental health as a vital health care need and to provide for those not able to do so themselves. Only when we as a country decide we no longer want to see the mentaly ill self medicating and sleeping rough like dogs will we put a dent in the problem.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
    • Alyssa replied to somchai on July 9, 2010

      Hey Somchai, Thanks so much for these insights. Mental health is definitely a huge factor in homelessness, and one that needs to be addressed at that. Totally with you on that.

      (Report comment)

      ↵ Reply
  • Reggiebean replied on July 26, 2010

    As someone from Colorado, I can say that our homeless population is getting ridiculous. It’s about time that it becomes illegal because you can barely walk down the sidewalk without having to step over someone trying to get money from you. Granted, there are those few that have become homeless through no fault on their own and need help, and shelters exist for that reason. I used to volunteer at one, so I know how they work. If someone genuinely needs help, something can always be done, even if we were at capacity. But 99% of our homeless population really are bums, who lie around all day trying to get money for their next drink. Something needs to be done to get them off our streets, once and for all.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
    • Alyssa replied to Reggiebean on July 27, 2010

      Hmmmm… well I supposed that’s your opinion and everyone is entitled, but we’ll have to agree to disagree. To me, it doesn’t really matter if someone is homeless through fault of their own, it’s still important that we care and try to get them the help they need, rather than criminalizing them in any capacity.

      Regardless, thanks for the insights.

      (Report comment)

      ↵ Reply
  • Karen L replied on August 29, 2010

    Wonderful article. San Francisco is quite famous for its homeless population. I walk through a homeless encapment every morning when I go to work. The first thing a lot of toursits comment on are the homeless and being harrassed by panhadlers. There definitely needs to be more resources for the homeless but we should also recognize that many homeless refuse to receive help even when it is there.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply

Leave a Comment

Get Matador in your inbox and around the web.

Sign up for our FREE weekly newsletter.


View full list of RSS feeds

Jump To Category:



Explore the Community



Popular Stories on Matador

Grow Some Moss in Your Bathroom

A soft grass carpet that thrives from the few drops of ... 

Stand-Up Paddle Surfing, Hurricane Style

Beginners, we suggest starting elsewhere.... 

The Way the Music Moves You Is Operation Beautiful

Our readers get busy making the world feel beautiful. ... 

An Out of Body Experience in the Heart of Gotham

Editor Alex Andrei takes an inner journey in an isolati... 

How To Make Your Own Flavored Vodka

The act of flavoring or "infusing" vodka yourself is no... 

Travel Photographer Interviews - Mathieu Young

Matador Editor at Large Paul Sullivan talks with Mathei... 

American Football vs. Rugby: Which is Tougher?

Matador attempts to put this old international sports d... 

How To Avoid Unwanted Conversations

... 

5 Matadorians to Meet Right Now: The Couples Edition

Two for the road!... 

10 Photography Books You'll Never Get Tired Of

Every one of these amazing and diverse photography book... 



Focus


Blogroll




Editor Blogs